Academic editor offers tips on handling rejection of peer-reviewed journal articles

The difference between mediocre academics and the stellar ones are how they handle rejections from academic journals.

Here are a few general tips from an academic editor to follow:

1. You’re not special. Every academic has received a rejection. You may think your work is beyond reproach, most researchers do. You’ve spent a lot of time on it, and it hurts to see your efforts appear wasted.
2. Your efforts weren’t wasted. Listen to the positives it the reviews — they’re in there. You did a lot right and should be proud of your work.
3. Now, focus on the negatives. What are the structural problems with your work? How can you address them? Remember that excessive or snarky negativity is a sign of weakness from your reviewer — some reviewers have issues that have nothing to do with your ability.
4. Be transparent in your methodology. If problems were pointed out in how you approached your study, simply admit to those problems in the methodology. Explain why, despite the problems, your paper still adds valid information to the field.
5. Consider wholesale changes. Dropping or severely revising one area of your study is not out of the question. Why not narrow or eliminate the section that causes the most reviewer concern?
6. Count on new reviewers. Remember that different reviewers will view your next draft. They aren’t aware of your last draft. If you’ve revised well, they will see your work as far more cohesive, complete and well-written.
7. Don’t stop at two submissions. Many authors have published their manuscript on the third or fourth try. That’s why there are so many journals out there.
8. Get to work. Sometimes we think the work required on the revision will take far longer than it really does. A revision can often be completed over the weekend. Stop procrastinating.

Now brush yourself off and get to work revising your manuscript.

Academic proofreading

Academic proofreading services offered by Oxford Editing. 

When you send the manuscript through our website, we immediately assess the requirements you identified on the form and send out an inquiry via email to make sure that we did not miss any important information, such as the journal name and any requisite formatting or style. We then match your paper with the appropriate editor, who prepares a 500-word sample edit that will show you how your editor will edit the rest of your manuscript. This sample edit also helps us to identify the level of edit your paper requires and to calculate the cost of editing your document based on the level of editing. We ask that you send your entire document and not select out a small portion. This way, your editor can start editing from the beginning, and we can evaluate the whole document to see if it would benefit from a structural edit. We will treat your document with the greatest confidentiality.

Academic editing and proofreading services

Best academic editing

Oxford Editing, we work to improve the written word. Send us your document, and we will pore over it with meticulous care. Whether your writing requires a final proofread or a thorough rewrite, our professional editors are ready to help. We offer English-language editing services at affordable rates with a quick turnaround.

top-rated academic editing 
Our experienced and professional English-language editors specialize in editing articles for academic journals, theses and dissertations, and books. We also can edit other materials, such as documentation, grants and proposals, and business writing. We edit in British or American English, depending on the publication. If you are searching for an academic editor, an ESL editor, a book or article editor, or an IT or business editor, then you have come to the right place.
  
good academic editing services, proofreading service, academic editing service, editing service
  
best editing, 
good editing, 
expert editing, 
journal editing, 
top-rated editing, 
professional editing, 
medical editing, 
medical writing, 
scientific editing, 
non-native English editing
ESL proofreading, 
academic proofreading, 
fast editing, 
English editing, 
PhD editor, 
accounting editing, 
finance editing, 
academic copy editing, 
copyediting, 
substantive editing, 
dissertation editing, 
ESL editorial services, 
professional proofreading, 
british english editing, 
book editing, 
grant writing, 
grantwriting, 
fiction 

Most of our editors hold post-graduate degrees, and many have PhDs and have published in peer-reviewed journals and presented papers at academic conferences.

Our professional editors can do much more than fix grammatical mistakes — we can also make substantial suggestions to improve your writing. We can closely examine your manuscript for structural flaws, including poor sentence flow, weak argumentation, and unsupported assertions. Our editors’ expertise will increase your chances of publication.

Oxford Editing understands the rigors of academic publishing. We will guide you in the unwritten rules of journal article acceptance (e.g., “don’t miss an opportunity to restate your argument,” “write in the active voice,” or “explain to the reader the importance of that quote.”) We are also familiar with all the major style manuals, including APA, MLA, Hart, Harvard, Turabian, and Chicago. Oxford Editing can help ensure that your document meets journal submission requirements.

To get a glimpse of what we do, you can submit a portion of your text for a no-obligation, sample edit. To do so, please click on the link below.

proofreading



dissertation editing 

thesis editing 

book editing 

fiction editing 

best english editing company 

English language proofreading 

English proofreading 

english editing and proofreading company 

Our editors have extensive experience helping academic authors revise their manuscripts into cogent and polished articles that are ready for publication. We know the academic journal requirements. For example, we can help a science writer rethink the way data is presented in a table so that a journal will accept it for publication. Our service can make the difference between publication and rejection.

online english editing company professional editing services online professional editing services English proofreading service good English editing company technical editing history editor professional proofreading top english editing service paper editing professional proofreading and editing services of scientific papers 

Professional Editing Services

If you need help revising or rewriting your manuscript, require an English-language expert to copyedit, or just want a fresh set of eyes to review or proof your manuscript before you submit it, our editors can help. We can proofread or copyedit to improve grammar and sentence flow without changing the sense and style of your writing. Our substantive and developmental editing services can help identify structural weaknesses, such as repetition or weak substantiation or your argument. All of our editorial services follow the highest publishing industry standards.

scientific editing expert scientific editor best scientific editing ESL scientific editing medical proofreading 

Critique of The National's "A day on the red line"

This is a critique of the National's "A Day on the Red Line" multi-media presentation.

WRITE YOUR CRITIQUE.

Marietta Church

Unity North Atlanta Church -- Spiritual, not religious church serving east Cobb, Roswell, Marietta

A dynamic spiritual community where The Kingdom of Heaven is a here-and-now present experience. We anchor Heaven here on earth through what we think and how we act.

As we open our hearts and love one another, we begin to live in the Kingdom of Love. At Unity North, we teach from many of the world's sacred scriptures and we believe there are many paths, but only One Presence.

Dr. Horrible

Academic Editing

Click here if you're searching for an academic editor.

At Oxford Editing, we work to improve the written word. Send us your document and we'll pore over it with meticulous care. Whether your project requires a quick overview or a thorough re-write, our seasoned editors are ready to help. We offer English-language editing services at affordable rates with quick turnaround.

Click on the academic editing link.